HomeNewsShadow of the Erdtree is an almost perfect expansion, but one thing...

Shadow of the Erdtree is an almost perfect expansion, but one thing keeps bothering me

Elden Ring’s Shadow of the Erdtree growth has a tall legacy to stay as much as. It’s, in spite of everything, constructing on the premise of one of many biggest video games of all time. As I mentioned in my preview and James reiterates in his evaluate, ‘extra of the identical’ isn’t so unhealthy when ‘the identical’ is a real all-timer.

The brand new journey throughout the DLC’s Land of Shadow isn’t all fully ‘the identical’, in fact. There’s new bosses, new weapons, and a brand new feeling – the construction of the brand new map feels somewhat totally different, a better diploma of density resulting in what actually feels prefer it forces the participant into extra lateral considering and navigational puzzle fixing, notably to unlock and totally discover all 5 segments of the shadowy realm that makes up the growth’s map.

Truthfully, it’s fairly near excellent, as expansions go. And but… there are parts of it that left me feeling only a tiny bit hole as I watched the DLC’s remaining boss fall beneath my blade. In honesty, which may very properly be the sensation FromSoftware was going for – if any developer is nice at hollowing gamers out, it’s them – nevertheless it’s curious.

The Tarnished entering the Gravesite Plain in Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC for the first time.

It is all a bit… grave. | Picture credit score: FromSoftware/VG247

None of this, actually, is about how the DLC performs. That is one in all my favourite varieties of DLC – builders of a large sport turning all the pieces as much as eleven, utilizing the entire tips of the commerce they’d realized within the arduous years of improvement on the core sport to craft one thing new, from scratch. Which means it surprises and delights by doing issues the builders hadn’t thought themselves capable of do the primary time round. It additionally means the entire thing has the whiff of a biggest hits package deal. Shadow of the Erdtree is that gig the place a band performs an unimaginable medley of its biggest hits from its break-out album to a packed mega-stadium of screaming followers.

That biggest hits ingredient might be the place a few of my frustration comes from, although. From a story perspective, I really feel like Shadow of the Erdtree is attractive, attention-grabbing, and (in true FromSoftware style) raises as many new attention-grabbing questions because it solutions. However I additionally really feel prefer it finally ends up ringing somewhat hole.

I believe an incredible diploma of that is right down to have actually separated Shadow of the Erdtree is from the remainder of the story. As soon as the DLC is downloaded and put in, one in all its key new NPCs seems in The Lands Between proper on the teleport level that takes you to the Land of Shadow, strategically positioned to provide the participant somewhat push. After which… properly, it’s all separate.

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree key art of a person with long, blonde hair riding on a horse-like creature in a field of wheat filled with ghostly graves.

The lands, they’re a-changing. | Picture credit score: FromSoftware

I began a brand new sport plus run to be able to have maiden Melina current, as a result of I believed she’d inevitably have one thing to say. She doesn’t. Again at Roundtable Maintain, good outdated all-knowing Gideon just isn’t all in favour of growing his information; no dialogue is added to his menus. Certainly the Finger Crone is that I’m handing her the Boss Remembrance of [REDACTED], and what meaning for the world’s whole perception system?! Not a line is uttered.

I’m advised by these which might be intimately conversant in FromSoftware’s know-how, engine, and sport development that that is, doubtless, largely technical. Inserting new occasions into Elden Ring’s story because it exists could be vastly sophisticated and danger breaking tenuously-scripted occasions. Many video games have narrative scripting that’s principally held along with chewing gum. I additionally personally know the way simply Elden Ring’s story scripting can shatter into 1,000,000 items underneath the remotest pressure from woes with the pre-release evaluate construct. I get it. On the identical time, nonetheless, I can’t assist however really feel disillusioned.

Within the case of Melina, specifically, it feels weird to me that there’s not even a line or two for gamers who enter the Land of Shadow together with her nonetheless in tow to handle her absence thereafter. A line on the first Website of Grace you go to, the place she says, “I can’t accompany you right here” or no matter, could be sufficient. It’d promote the connection between the 2 worlds. Because it stands, it appears like there’s no connection. It appears like this might’ve been launched as a stand-alone DLC story; the story of a special character.

Melina in Elden Ring.

Nothing to say? | Picture credit score: VG247/FromSoftware

All of that is made barely stranger by the way in which the DLC is structured. New tools and abilities gained within the Land of Shadow may be taken again to The Lands Between. In reality, gamers are inspired to criss-cross the worlds, as you’ll be anticipated to move again to Roundtable Maintain to be able to improve gear, cope with Remembrances, and so forth. This combines with the truth that Shadow of the Erdtree engages in an aggressive box-ticking train of answering main fan questions in regards to the lore and backstory of Elden Ring to make it really feel a bit unusual: you be taught issues that change all the pieces about all the pieces, slay legends and myths – and there’s usually no acknowledgement of it, not even an additional line of dialogue.

There’s meals for thought right here in how DLC content material like this integrates into the sprawl of huge present adventures – and the way I believe it’s changing into a necessity to have your world react at the least a little. Again within the 360 period, BioWare’s Mass Impact DLCs all the time had little repercussions, even when they had been simply new conversations together with your crew. Cyberpunk 2077 Phantom Liberty is presumably the gold commonplace for this, with quests that weave out and in of the primary sport’s landmass in a extremely satisfying manner.

I’m not saying DLC can’t be discrete and separate, both – nevertheless it actually must be constructed that manner. The Witcher 3: Blood & Wine has subsequent to nothing to do with the primary sport, and is fully siloed off – however that feels proper. That’s a narrative about Geralt occurring somewhat tour, in spite of everything. A vacation. Shadow of the Erdtree just isn’t that; it’s full of revelation in regards to the Lands Between and lots of of its key figures – nevertheless it feels impossibly distant.

Shadow of the Erdtree continues to be indisputably among the best video games of the yr. I had a blast enjoying it. However this reveals that even essentially the most mighty builders can’t get all of it 100% proper the entire time. And that’s advantageous – if something, it makes me much more excited for his or her subsequent sport. A extra reactive world subsequent time, maybe?


Shadow of the Erdtree is the large $40 Elden Ring growth, and it’s the one one the sport might be getting. It arrives June 21 on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Sequence X/S, and requires proudly owning a duplicate of the bottom sport.

See also  Payday 3 Hopes to Address Community Concerns With Operation Medic Bag, 2024 Plans Revealed
RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular